<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="static/style.xsl"?><OAI-PMH xmlns="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/ http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/OAI-PMH.xsd"><responseDate>2026-11-21T07:07:45Z</responseDate><request verb="GetRecord" identifier="oai:macsphere.mcmaster.ca:11375/15588" metadataPrefix="dim">https://prod-ms-be.lib.mcmaster.ca/server/oai/request</request><GetRecord><record><header><identifier>oai:macsphere.mcmaster.ca:11375/15588</identifier><datestamp>2026-09-24T06:03:29Z</datestamp><setSpec>com_11375_271</setSpec><setSpec>col_11375_272</setSpec></header><metadata><dim:dim xmlns:dim="http://www.dspace.org/xmlns/dspace/dim" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:doc="http://www.lyncode.com/xoai" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.dspace.org/xmlns/dspace/dim http://www.dspace.org/schema/dim.xsd">
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="contributor" qualifier="advisor">Eyles, John</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="contributor" qualifier="author">Butz, David Aaron Otto</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="contributor" qualifier="department" lang="en_US">Geography</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="date" qualifier="accessioned">2014-08-05T16:01:42Z</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="date" qualifier="available">2014-08-05T16:01:42Z</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="date" qualifier="issued">1993</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="identifier" qualifier="uri">http://hdl.handle.net/11375/15588</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="identifier" qualifier="uri">https://doi.org/10.71548/14612</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="description" qualifier="abstract" lang="en_US">Conventional approaches to evaluating international development programmes undervalue&#xd;
the local contexts within which development initiatives occur. Programmes are most often assessed&#xd;
according to economic criteria, which do not fully represent the aspirations and concerns of&#xd;
community members. Consequently, formal development evaluations are poor reflections of a&#xd;
programme's total influence on the social organisation of communities and the daily lives of&#xd;
community members.&#xd;
Two objectives guided my research. The first was to develop an approach to evaluating&#xd;
rural development programmes, at the level of individual communities, which was more sensitive&#xd;
to indigenous social contexts and priorities than are conventional approaches. My second objective&#xd;
was to demonstrate the utility of this new approach by using it to evaluate the influence of Aga&#xd;
Khan Rural Support Programme (AKRSP) initiatives on Shimshal community, Pakistan. The first&#xd;
objective was theoretical; the second, empirical.&#xd;
The study begins by addressing the initial objective with two major theoretical points. First,&#xd;
draw from the critical social theory of Habermas to develop the concept of community&#xd;
sustainability, which I offer as a universally acceptable standard against which to evaluate the&#xd;
results of development programmes. Community sustainability is defined as follows: (a) a&#xd;
universally desirable, ideal state; (b) in which community members' shared norms and supporting&#xd;
institutions are established consensually; (c) where decisions are validated according to those&#xd;
shared norms within accepted institutions; and (d) where those norms and institutions, and changes&#xd;
to them, are supported through time by the material resources available to the community.&#xd;
According to this conception programmes should be evaluated in tenns of their influence on&#xd;
community decision making processes, and not on specific technical innovations.&#xd;
Second, I employ Matthews' sociological work to suggest that we can evaluate the&#xd;
contribution of development programmes to community sustainability by examining their influence on decision making in four areas of organisation: social, political, economic, and ecological. These,&#xd;
when integrated with the larger concept of community sustainability, facilitate the identification and&#xd;
definition of four categories according to which community sustainability can be empirically&#xd;
evaluated: social vitality, political validity, economic viability, and ecological volition.&#xd;
I applied this framework to interpreting the nature of sustainability in Shimshal community,&#xd;
in northern Pakistan, and to evaluating the influence of an initiative by the Aga Khan Rural Support&#xd;
Programme to create village organisations in Shimshal. Two main research strategies were&#xd;
employed. First, I analysed historical and contemporary texts to provide the following contextual&#xd;
understandings: (a} Shimshalis' formal interpretation of their community; (b) outsiders' historical and&#xd;
contemporary perspectives on Shimshal; (c) the history of community sustainability in Hunza (of&#xd;
which Shimshal is a part) over the past two centuries; and (d) the objectives and achievements of&#xd;
the Aga Khan Rural Support Programme in the villages of northern Pakistan.&#xd;
Second, I engaged in seven months of ethnographic fieldwork in the community of&#xd;
Shimshal. Field notes collected during my two visits were coded along two dimensions: (a} into four&#xd;
theoretically-derived categories (social, political, economic or ecological); and (b} into inductive&#xd;
categories, each of which represented some theme or narrative of Shimshali lived experience {eg.&#xd;
formal education} relating to the creation of AKRSP village organisations. These two dimensions&#xd;
of analysis integrate in an interpretation that utilises small case studies to assess the influence of&#xd;
AKRSP initiatives on the sustainability of Shimshal's four areas of social organisation.&#xd;
This process of evaluation reveals that Shimshal has become more sustainable in the past&#xd;
half decade because village organisations created by the AKRSP have facilitated an increasingly&#xd;
consensual form of decision making within an increasingly rationalised culture and society. That&#xd;
AKRSP village organisations have facilitated this change is due mainly to the social and cultural&#xd;
context of Shimshal, particularly an indigenous tendency toward community autonomy and&#xd;
collective decision making. The study's significance relates to its initial objectives. First, the approach to evaluating&#xd;
agency development I advanced improves on conventional approaches to programme evaluation,&#xd;
and also contributes to the evaluation of social change more generally. Second, the application of&#xd;
this evaluation approach to AKRSP development in Shimshal contributes to AKRSP's practical&#xd;
understanding of the influence of its endeavours in Shimshal, and provides guidance for improving&#xd;
development efforts in Shimshal and elsewhere within its programme area.</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="description" qualifier="degreetype" lang="en_US">Thesis</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="description" qualifier="degree" lang="en_US">Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="language" qualifier="iso" lang="en_US">en_US</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="subject" lang="en_US">Sustainability</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="subject" lang="en_US">Community</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="title" lang="en_US">Developing Sustainable Communities: Community Development and Modernity in Shimshal</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="dc" element="type" lang="en_US">Thesis</dim:field>
   <dim:field mdschema="others" element="access-status">open.access</dim:field>
</dim:dim></metadata></record></GetRecord></OAI-PMH>